Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements (ICHRAs) give employers a fundamentally different way to provide health benefits. Instead of selecting one group health insurance plan for everyone, employers can establish a defined contribution and allow eligible employees to purchase individual health insurance coverage that works for them.

That flexibility, however, comes with compliance responsibilities.

As ICHRA adoption continues to grow, employers, brokers, and benefits professionals need to understand not only what an ICHRA allows, but also what it does not allow.

Here are five ICHRA compliance mistakes employers should understand and avoid.

1. Limiting Employees to One Individual Policy or Restricting Their ACA Plan Choices

A key concept behind ICHRA is individual choice.

The employer establishes the reimbursement arrangement and determines the amount available under the plan. The employee then obtains qualifying individual health insurance coverage.

A potential compliance problem arises when an employer, broker, or other party structures an ICHRA in a way that effectively limits employees to one individual insurance policy or unnecessarily restricts the ACA-compliant individual health insurance options available to them.

The ICHRA should not become a disguised group health plan where someone selects a single individual policy and tells every employee, “This is the plan you have to buy.”

Brokers can provide valuable assistance by educating employees, helping them understand available coverage, and supporting the individual-market shopping process. However, the concept of employee-selected coverage should remain intact.

How to Avoid Common Policy Restriction Mistakes

  • Make sure enrollment support assists employees with making a choice rather than making a choice for them.
  • Give employees access to the qualifying individual-market options available to them.
  • Avoid requiring all employees to purchase the same individual policy.
  • Do not design an ICHRA around a single carrier or policy simply for administrative convenience.
  • Allow employees to evaluate premiums, networks, formularies, deductibles, and other coverage differences.

Compliance Tip: With ICHRA, the employer chooses the contribution. The employee chooses the individual coverage that meets the applicable ICHRA requirements.

This distinction is important because employee choice is not merely a marketing advantage of ICHRA. It is part of what separates the individual-coverage model from traditional employer-selected group health insurance.

2. Reimbursing Employees Who Do Not Have Qualifying Coverage

An ICHRA is not simply a pool of employer money that an employee can use toward any healthcare-related coverage.

To receive ICHRA reimbursements, employees must be enrolled in qualifying individual health coverage, Medicare, or another permitted coverage type.

Not every product that looks like health coverage qualifies.

Health sharing plans, short-term plans, MEC-only arrangements, and coverage through a spouse’s group health plan generally do not satisfy the individual coverage requirement for ICHRA reimbursements.

That distinction is critical.

An employer may have an otherwise properly designed ICHRA, but reimbursements still need to be connected to qualifying coverage.

Precautions Employers Should Take to Avoid This Mistake

  • Work with an experienced ICHRA administrator that understands coverage verification.
  • Verify qualifying coverage before reimbursements begin.
  • Follow annual coverage-verification requirements.
  • Require appropriate substantiation for reimbursements.
  • Maintain documentation according to the plan’s administrative procedures.

Compliance Tip: Having “health coverage” does not automatically mean an employee has coverage that qualifies them for ICHRA reimbursements.

3. Improperly Combining ICHRA and Group Health Insurance or Misusing Employee Classes

One of the biggest ICHRA misconceptions is that an employer can simply give individual employees a choice:

“Would you like our traditional group health plan, or would you rather have an ICHRA?”

Generally, that is not how ICHRA works.

An employer may offer a traditional group health plan to one permitted employee class and an ICHRA to another, but employees within the same class generally cannot choose between the two.

That makes proper employee classification an essential part of ICHRA plan design.

ICHRA allows employers to structure benefits around permitted employment characteristics, including full-time versus part-time employees, salaried versus hourly employees, seasonal employees, and employees in different geographic rating areas.

For example, an employer may be able to retain its traditional group health plan for employees at its headquarters while establishing an ICHRA for a qualifying geographic class of remote employees.

However, employee classes cannot simply be created around which employees an employer would prefer to move off the group health plan.

Minimum class-size requirements can also apply when certain employee classes are used to divide employees between a traditional group plan and an ICHRA.

Depending upon the circumstances, applicable minimum class sizes may include:

  • Fewer than 100 employees: Minimum class size of 10 employees
  • 100 to 200 employees: Minimum class size of 10% of the workforce
  • More than 200 employees: Minimum class size of 20 employees

Not every permitted class is subject to these minimums, making careful ICHRA Plan Design important.

Precautions Employers Should Take to Avoid This Mistake include

  • Build the ICHRA around permitted employee classes.
  • Apply class definitions consistently.
  • Do not give employees within the same class a choice between ICHRA and the traditional group plan.
  • Evaluate minimum class-size requirements when offering both types of coverage.
  • Review geographic classifications when designing benefits for remote and multistate employees.
  • Document eligibility and contribution methodology.

Compliance Tip: Do not start by deciding which individual employees you would like to move onto ICHRA. Start with the permitted employee classes and build your benefits strategy from there.

Learn more in our guide to defining ICHRA employee classes.

4. Treating an ICHRA Like an Informal Premium Reimbursement Program

Another common misconception is:

“We’ll just give employees money to buy their own health insurance.”

While that might sound like ICHRA at its most basic level, a compliant ICHRA involves much more.

An ICHRA is an employer-sponsored health reimbursement arrangement governed by specific requirements. Simply paying or reimbursing an employee for an individual insurance premium without properly establishing and administering the arrangement should not be confused with offering an ICHRA.

A properly constructed program involves plan design, documentation, employee notices, substantiation, coverage verification, reimbursement procedures, and ongoing administration.

How to Avoid Mistake #4

  • Establish formal ICHRA plan documents.
  • Provide required employee notices.
  • Clearly define eligibility and contribution methodology.
  • Verify qualifying individual coverage.
  • Properly substantiate reimbursement requests.
  • Maintain consistent administrative procedures.
  • Work with an experienced third-party administrator.

Compliance Tip: If it looks like an ICHRA, it needs to operate like an ICHRA.

5. Assuming Regulators Are Not Paying Attention

ICHRA is still a relatively young benefits strategy. The federal regulations establishing ICHRA were issued in 2019, with ICHRAs becoming available beginning in 2020.

That newness can create a false sense of security.

Employers may assume that because they have not heard about widespread ICHRA enforcement activity, compliance is not an immediate concern.

That is a risky long-term strategy.

As ICHRA adoption increases, employers, administrators, brokers, carriers, regulators, and other benefits professionals are gaining greater experience with how these arrangements should operate.

Employers should therefore build their ICHRA strategy around long-term compliance rather than waiting until an administrative problem or regulatory question arises.

How to Stay Compliant in ICHRA

  • Work with experienced ICHRA administration and benefits professionals.
  • Conduct periodic ICHRA compliance reviews.
  • Review employee eligibility and classifications.
  • Audit plan administration procedures.
  • Keep plan documentation current.
  • Monitor changes in ICHRA regulations and guidance.
  • Review how employees are being presented with individual-market options.

Compliance Tip: The best time to identify a compliance problem is before an auditor or regulator does.

ICHRA Flexibility, Choice, and Compliance Must Work Together

ICHRA has changed the conversation around employer-sponsored health benefits.

Employers gain greater flexibility to define their healthcare contribution and design benefits around permitted segments of their workforce. At the same time, eligible employees gain the ability to select individual coverage that better fits their own healthcare needs.

That last piece is particularly important.

ICHRA is not designed to replace one employer-selected group plan with one employer-selected individual plan.

The employer determines the benefit design and contribution. Employees then use that benefit toward qualifying individual coverage available to them.

A strong ICHRA strategy therefore brings three principles together:

Employer cost control + employee choice + compliant plan administration.

Employers, brokers, and administrators all have a role in protecting that structure.

The goal should be to provide employees with the education and enrollment support necessary to make informed decisions without unnecessarily limiting their access to qualifying individual coverage.

Organizations that understand employee classifications, individual coverage choice, qualifying coverage requirements, reimbursements, documentation, and ongoing administration will be better positioned to take advantage of ICHRA without introducing unnecessary compliance risk.

Want to Learn More About ICHRA?

If your organization is considering an ICHRA (Choice-Arrangements) or evaluating an existing arrangement, understanding the rules is an important first step.

Start by learning more about ICHRA employee classes and how they can be used.

Flyte HCM works with employers and benefits professionals to administer ICHRA arrangements, including plan documentation, notices, reimbursement administration, and ongoing plan support.

The goal is not simply to offer an ICHRA. It is to build an ICHRA strategy that provides employer cost control, preserves employee choice, and is administered correctly.